Challenges of Digital Transformation in Pesantren in the 2018– 2026 Literature: A Systematic Literature Review
Keywords:
Digital transformation, Pesantren, Digital Literacy, Educational Technology, Systematic Literature ReviewAbstract
Digital transformation offers pesantren opportunities to improve learning, administration, communication, and access to knowledge, but adoption also raises infrastructure, human-capacity, governance, and cultural challenges. This article reviews literature published between 2018 and 2026 to map the principal challenges discussed in research on digital transformation in Indonesian pesantren. A structured literature review was developed using targeted searches of scholarly web indexes and journal repositories, with terms relating to pesantren, digitalization, information technology, learning, and management. Relevant publications were screened for topical relevance and synthesized thematically. The accessible literature points to five interrelated challenge areas: unequal access to stable internet and suitable devices; uneven digital literacy among educators and students; limited institutional capacity for planning, maintenance, and data governance; pedagogical integration that may remain at the level of using tools rather than redesigning learning; and the need to protect religious learning traditions, privacy, and ethical conduct in digital environments. Studies also describe constructive uses of technology in teaching and institutional administration, suggesting that digital adoption is not inherently opposed to pesantren identity. Instead, outcomes depend on leadership, staff development, infrastructure, and clear educational purposes. The review is exploratory because the search and screening records have not yet been independently reproduced across all major databases; therefore, it does not claim a complete PRISMA count or exhaustive coverage. The article concludes that a context-sensitive, staged, and values-based transformation strategy is more appropriate than technology procurement alone.