COMPARISON OF THE DELONE AND MCLEAN MODEL, TAM, AND UTAUT IN ISLAMIC EDUCATION MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEMS: A COMPARATIVE LITERATURE REVIEW
Keywords:
DeLone and McLean, Technology Acceptance Mdoel (TAM), UTAUT, Management Information Systems, Islamic Education ManagementAbstract
The development of information technology has encouraged Islamic educational institutions to utilize Management Information Systems (MIS) to improve administrative processes, academic services, and decision-making. However, the success of information systems is not only determined by the availability of technology but also by the level of user acceptance and the benefits provided by the system. This study aims to compare the DeLone and McLean Information Systems Success Model, the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), and the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) in the context of Management Information Systems in Islamic education. This study employs a comparative literature review method by examining relevant scientific articles and previous research discussing information systems, technology acceptance, and educational management. The analysis focuses on the main concepts, measurement dimensions, strengths, limitations, and applicability of each model in Islamic educational institutions. The comparative analysis indicates that the DeLone and McLean model is more suitable for evaluating information system quality, user satisfaction, and the benefits generated by system use. TAM focuses on perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use in explaining technology acceptance, while UTAUT provides a broader perspective by considering performance expectations, effort expectations, social influence, and facilitating conditions. These models offer complementary perspectives for understanding information system implementation in Islamic educational management. This study concludes that model selection should be adjusted to the research objectives, institutional conditions, and characteristics of system users. Integrating the three models may also provide a more comprehensive framework for evaluating information system success and technology acceptance in Islamic educational institutions.